Custom Cookies — almost too beautiful to eat
Designed and handcrafted by Lisa Riley, every cookie is a piece of art. Choose your design, size, colors, and intricacy — and enjoy cookies that taste even better than they look.
Start your cookie order See how it works ↓
500+ cookies crafted and enjoyed last year!
Create your dream cookies in 3 easy steps
01
Choose your design
Pick shapes, themes, and share your vision. Whether classic or whimsical, Lisa can create it.
02
Pick size and colors
Decide how big you want your cookies, and how many colors you'd like for your design.
03
Choose level of intricacy
From simple to stunningly intricate, Lisa handcrafts each cookie to your exact preference.
A design for every moment
Grad Cap
Easter Fun
Chocolate Chip Goodness
Spooky Crew
Merica Mixer
Perfect for:
- Weddings
- Birthdays
- Baby Showers
- Holidays
- Corporate Events
- Bridal Showers
- Engagement Parties
- Anniversaries
- Teacher Gifts
- Graduation Celebrations
- Retirement Parties
- Housewarming Gifts
- Gender Reveals
- Sports Team Parties
Our cookies make memories
I couldn't believe how gorgeous the cookies were. And somehow, they tasted even better!
— Jennifer L.
Lisa is truly an artist. My daughter's birthday cookies stole the show!
— Jules S.
Absolute work of art! And the taste was phenomenal!
— Kylee G.
Custom pricing for every design
Simple
Starting at $36/dozen
Basic shapes, 1-2 colors, minimal detail.
Intricate
Starting at $60/dozen
Multiple colors and detailed, custom designs.
Let's make your cookie vision real!
Contact Lisa Riley at My Makery Bakery and start designing today. We can't wait to create for you!